As published in HPCWire

Feast or Famine: A Hungry Analyst’s Review of SC08

It happens every year at the Supercomputing Conference and Expo, whether it’s seafood in Seattle, pierogies in Pittsburgh, or anchos in Austin. Some
days it’s a feast, others a famine.

For those of you who, like me, used SC08 as an opportunity to synch up with important contacts, you know the drill. Or rather, you know the two different
drills. In drill number one, you eat like a hobbit. After a 7:30 breakfast meeting you have a second breakfast meeting at 8:30. Then it’s elevenses
with your first lunch, followed by a proper lunch meeting that lasts a full hour. Fill up then, because you won’t eat again until the meet-and-greet
at 4:30, after which you have back-to-back dinners and at least two catered receptions to attend. You roll back to the hotel, and if you’re lucky,
you’re at the Doubletree, so you can eat a fresh chocolate chip and walnut cookie in bed. (Really, those cookies are very good.)

Drill number two doesn’t work that way. For whatever reason, your meetings line up differently the next day, and somehow you keep missing meals. If
you’re in the Doubletree, that delicious cookie is the only food you sniff all day. The Ritz will fetch you anything you want of course, but at
other hotels, you might just go to bed hungry, dreaming of the two brunches you’ll have tomorrow. The food is incidental, of course, and what really
matters is what you learn in the time you’re there. Just in time for American Thanksgiving, here’s a quick feast-or-famine guide to what you could
gorge on in the HPC space, versus areas in which the cupboard is bare.

Interconnect Options: Feast

At my second dinner Monday evening, one vendor asked me if I thought InfiniBand could continue to survive with Mellanox as the only chip provider.
Of course it could survive, I replied, because our data shows InfiniBand adoption continuing to grow in all interconnect segments. But it was likely
that this growth would attract new entrants, and we’d eventually have more than one player. The next day, QLogic announced its own chips, lending
a new option to a growing space.

Other sectors of the interconnect market are heating up as well. 10 Gigabit Ethernet has gone mainstream, with a wealth of vendors seeking to differentiate
their offerings. The most interesting of these may be Myricom, which has remodeled its business plan to derive a majority of its revenue from 10GbE.
But neither of these developments is where I see the real action heating up over the next two years. The big trend to watch is now optics. Users
in many verticals are expressing early interest in optical interconnects because of their potential in lowering latency. Avago, Finisar, Lightfleet,
Luxtera, and Obsidian all had presences at SC08, and Tabor Research predicts we’ll continue to see more from them over the next two years.

Utility Computing: Feast

Tabor Research surveys have shown a high degree of user interest in cloud computing. In this space, Arista made a splash by landing Silicon Valley
visionary Andy Bechtolsheim, who is now championing that company’s cloud strategy. In addition, a little-known company called Darkstrand made a
big impression with its commercialization of access to supercomputing resources over the National LambdaRail network. Even demos in The MathWorks’
booth showcased Amazon EC2. Cloud computing plays into the strengths of IBM and HP, the HPC server leaders, as well as Platform Computing, the
leading middleware provider. Tabor Research expects these three companies to capitalize on the opportunity.

Server Vendors’ Data Management Strategies: Famine

The evolution of pNFS is the most important story in HPC that no one is paying enough attention to. In beta now, pNFS will likely become a standard
option in the first half of 2009 and go mainstream by the end of the year. With data management as one of users’ most significant challenges, the
server vendor community has yet to fully embrace the landscape shift that will start to take place between now and SC09.

The storage vendors are largely ready. Panasas has been publicly pushing pNFS since early 2007, and companies ranging from BlueArc to NetApp are well-positioned
to gain from standardization in the file system arena. On the server side, the readiness is not as apparent, especially considering the big server
vendors all sell storage products.

The lone strategic bright spot seems to be on Sun, the same company that popularized InfiniBand as a storage interconnect. Sun’s Open Storage strategy
is at times confusing but indubitably bold and is the most significant area of Sun differentiation in HPC. Plus, Sun owns Lustre now; I just wish
they would do more with it. IBM has GPFS and will continue to ride that train successfully, at least for the near term. HP, Dell, and Cray all
need to work on their data management solutions.

Accelerator Options: Feast

The biggest new product news here is NVIDIA’s launch of its “personal supercomputer” based on its Tesla GPGPU. This exciting product has unfortunately
been labeled with an albatross of a designator — the industry is rife with failed, oxymoronic personal supercomputers — but NVIDIA may have the
clout and momentum to gain in academic and research markets while the marketing department figures out how to reposition for the industrial sector.
The ecosystem around Tesla also continues to grow. NVIDIA partners (notably Acceleware) are pre-packaging Tesla-based solutions, and The Portland
Group has been working on its own compilers for GPGPU. Intel’s Nehalem CPU is an important consideration in this space, but in this case I think
Intel’s competitive heat is on AMD more than it is on NVIDIA.

But while everyone has been looking at GPGPU, an older accelerator category has slipped back into the mix: FPGA. Before you scoff, consider that FPGAs
excel in areas in which GPGPUs have been weak, especially in scalable, high-bandwidth, text- or integer-based applications. This time around, programmability
isn’t at issue, because vendors like Convey, BlueArc, and XtremeData have integrated FPGAs into their offerings.

Convey enjoyed a terrific launch, thanks in part to the combined experience of Bruce Toal and Steve Wallach. (An interview with Wallach hit The New
York Times during the show.) The FPGA-powered design is a major departure in computing architectures, and Convey could quickly become an interesting
second-tier player alongside SiCortex, another differentiated architecture player with a strong SC08 showing.

Bring on the Next Course

Overall the energy of the show was strong, setting another attendance record (although that is as much a factor of the diversity of vendors than anything
else). Still, amid these famine-oriented economic conditions, the SC08 floor was a refreshing island of plenty. In our most recent surveys, users
indicated their budgets are still expected to grow over the next two years, and judging by the smorgasbord of activity in Austin, we could be ready
to feast again in Portland in 2009.

Posted in